COMMENTARY: THE
SCRAPBOOK INDEPENDENT
This issue has evolved into a special report on the state and
future of independent scrapbook retailers. It started with an email
from Lisa Kanak, owner of The Cropper's Corner. Her
thought-provoking letter (see below) got me thinking about how
scrapbooking is evolving, and perhaps it's becoming impossibly
difficult for the independents to survive and prosper. So I sent an
email to a number of retailers, vendors, and others asking their
opinions.
Boy, did I get them! The answers are divided in the various
columns listed below.
I don't agree with everyone's thoughts, but that's fine. A
subscriber once described CLN as "the industry's village
green, where everyone can come together and safely discuss
issues." That's exactly what I hope CLN is doing with
this issue. And if you have any comments on what you read, please
send them on or off the record to me at mike@clnonline.com.
NEW COLUMNS THIS ISSUE
Business-Wise.
Mike's original thoughts emailed to various industry sources
and an answers from two of the industry's top consultants.
Vinny Da
Vendor. Vendors respond, explaining why they sell/package
the way they do.
Category
Reports. Winners of TNNA's Star Stitchers and Student
Design Competition.
Scene &
Heard. The latest on Micah Jones, daughter of Marrijane
Jones of Offinger Management, who was seriously hurt just
prior to the CHA Summer Show. It's good news!
Note. If you surf to a column and it's an "old"
column, click the "Refresh" or "Reload" button
on your browser.
TAKE THE CLN POLL:
PREDICT DESIGN TRENDS
Gifts & Decorative Accessories magazine is polling its
readers about future trends in design. We thought it would be
interesting to ask exactly the same question, then compare our
results with G&DA's. click on Industry Polls in the right-hand
column or HERE
-- and vote!
CLN
POLL: READERS SLIGHTLY
OPTIMISTIC
We asked CLN readers to predict how the national economy
and their business would perform during the remainder of 2004,
including the all-important holiday season.
National Economy. No one predicted strong growth or that the
economy would decline significantly ... 39% predicted it would
improve "slightly" ... 39% thought the economy would be
flat ... 22% expect a slight decline.
Business. 8.7% predict their business will increase
significantly ... 43.5% expect a slight increase ... 34.8% think
their business will be flat with last season ... 4.4% predict a
slight decline ... 8.7% expect a significant decline in their
business.
MICHAELS: STRONG QUARTER,
OPTIMISTIC FUTURE
Thanks to comments at the recent vendor meetings, the second
quarter earnings report, and President/CEO Michael Rouleau's
comments during a conference call with analysts, the company is
clearly not resting on its laurels even though those laurels are
pretty impressive:
1. For the three months ended July 31, earnings rose 10% to
$26.7 million ($0.38/share). The results included an after-tax
charge of $3 million to establish an insurance reserve because of
one of Michaels' insurance company's financial problems. Excluding
this charge, earnings/share would have been $0. 43/share. Analysts
surveyed by Thomson First Call had predicted earnings of
$0.40/share. Sales rose 10.8% to $682.9 and same-store sales were up
5%.
2. August same-store sales rose 5.0%; the results were better
than the vast majority of retailers in the U.S. (See article below)
3. The stock has risen more than $6 in the last three weeks.
It's now in the range it was when it split a couple of years ago.
4. Michaels opened its 1,000th store last month, in Winter
Park, FL. The 2004 schedule involves opening 45 and relocating 30
Michaels stores, opening seven and relocating one Aaron Brothers
store, and opening six Recollections stores. It will finish
the year with approximately 1,020 stores. There was no mention of Village
Craft stores, whose names will be changed to Michaels.
5. In his conference call Rouleau discussed plans to achieve
the "perfect store." Look for Michaels to spend the next
18 months to develop prototypes in five markets. After studying the
results and refining the prototype, the company will roll out the
"perfect store" in 2006.
The prototype's goal is to become a brand one that's a
continuing source for inspiration, fun, excitement, and creativity.
That will be achieved through better merchandising and signage, plus
classes, demos, and services such as custom framing and floral
arranging.
When asked about the previously stated goal of increasing sales
to $5 million/store, Rouleau said that would be achieved via the
"perfect store" concept.
AUGUST SALES: THE GLUM NEWS
CONTINUES
With very few exceptions (Michaels being one), August was
lousy. The only retail sector that weathered the storm were the
luxury-goods chains such as Neiman-Marcus, Nordstrom, and Saks Fifth
Avenue.
Reasons for the decline were plentiful: Hurricane Charley hurt
sales in Florida, high gas prices, a relatively late Labor Day,
faltering consumer confidence, rising interest rates, and fairly
strong sales a year ago, due in part to consumers receiving
tax-rebate checks. Dollar Tree CEO and former Michaels exec
Bob Sasser said on a conference call, "It is no secret that the
retail environment has been tough in general," CBS MarketWatch
reported.
Back-to-school sales were lackluster as customer traffic dropped
to its lowest level since March, 2003, the National Retail
Federation reported. "People are not spending money," Kurt
Barnard, head of Retail Forecasting Group, told Reuters. "They
are intimidated by the [economic] outlook."
Michaels. Overall sales rose 10.0% to $205.1 million and
same-store sales increased 5.0%. Sales for the year are up 11.0% to
$1.614 billion. For the month, customer traffic was up 3%, the
average ticket was down 1%, and custom frame deliveries were up 3%.
CEO/President Michael Rouleau said, "Overall, we are pleased
with our sales results for August. Our best performing departments
were yarn, frames, impulse/party, and kids crafts, and our strongest
zones were the Pacific, Northeast, and Northern. We continue to
expect September same-store sales to be relatively flat and October
same-store sales to increase 4% to 6%, with custom frame deliveries
shifting from September into August and October."
Michaels continues to expect earnings to be $0.62 - $0.65 for the
quarter and $2.92 - $3.05 for the year.
Jo-Ann's. Same-store sales decreased 2.9%. Analysts had
expected a 4% decline, Dow Jones News reported. A year ago Jo-Ann's
enjoyed a 9.8% increase thanks to the company's 60th anniversary
promotion, which obviously was not repeated. Execs said the lack of
a promotion hurt sales but helped margins. Sales for the year are
still up 4.6% and same-store sales are up 3.8% compared to last
year's 3.5%.
Wal-Mart. Same-store sales gained only 0.5% (the lowest gain
we can ever remember), which was at the low end of the discounter's
already lowered prediction, and below analysts' expectations.
Wal-Mart also announced its earnings for the third quarter will
likely reach only the low end of its forecast for $0.52 -
$0.54/share, also lower than analysts' expectations, Reuters
reported. Wal-Mart also lowered its prediction for quarterly
same-store sales growth from 3-5% to 2-4%.
Hancock. Same-store sales inched upward by 0.2% and overall
sales rose $100,000 to $30.7 million. For the first seven months of
the fiscal year, sales are down 3.7% to $225.6 and same-store sales
fell 4.2%.
Some winners: Nieman Marcus, +14.7% ... Nordstrom, +7.2% ...
Chico's, +3.6% ... Best Buy, +4.3% ... J.C. Penney, +3.8% ... Dollar
General, +2.8% ... Target, +1.8%.
Some losers: Family Dollar, -0.1% ... ShopKo, -0.2% ...
Kohl's, -0.7% ... Big Lots, -2.0% ... Limited, -2.0% ... Federated
Department Stores, -2.4% ... Duckwall-ALCO, -2.7% ... Pier 1
Imports, -2.8% ... Ann Taylor, -4.5% ... Abercrombie & Fitch,
-5.0% ... Dillard's, -5.0% ... May Department Stores, -5.9% ...
Sears, -6.1% ... Bombay, -19.0%.
Help may be on the way, however. On Friday the Labor Department
reported employers added 144,000 workers to payrolls in August, the
most since May, and revised upward the number of jobs created in
July 73,000, twice the original estimate.
CHA OFFERS AN INSPIRATION
& DESIGN FAIRE
The Craft & Hobby Assn. Winter Show will include a new
exhibit area dedicated to showcasing art and design. CHAs Inspiration
& Design Faire will provide designers with a venue to
exhibit their creative services and conduct business. The Show is
Feb. 12-15 in Atlanta.
The new section will feature those who design, create or license
two-dimensional or three-dimensional work in key areas such as
advertising art, crafts, decorative art, giftware, florals, home dec,
kids crafts, paper art, and more. Manufacturers, publishers, and
buyers seeking ideas for product and kit development, project
sheets, booth display, TV work, and other creative projects will
find the talent they need at the Faire, says Anita Collins,
CHAs director of member programs and services.
"The time has come to give the CHA designer member section
and all industry designers their proper recognition," Collins
says, "because all successful products were inspired by great
design." Collins said. For exhibit info, visit www.chashow.org
or call 201-794-1133.
EMAIL: PAPER/STICKER PACKAGES
ARE TOO LARGE!
(Note: In the 8/16/04 issue, CLN commented,
"Scrapbook vendors tell CLN the #1 reason why
independents go out of business is poor inventory control."
That prompted the following from Lisa Kanak, owner of The
Cropper's Corner, a Crafter's Home store in
Fredericksburg, VA.)
I'm an independent who's frustrated; I'm told I need to turn
my inventory not less than 6x/year, but at the same time I
"have" to purchase in depths that I know won't turn in 3+
months.
It's a fact that the vast majority of papers and rolled stickers
(sold in 50s), won't turn in 2 months and over 50% won't turn in
4 months. There will always be a handful that do (but you never know
which ones). In my store, I can count on one hand the number of
stickers we have turned 50 or more (at regular price) of in the last
7 months they are all from one vendor, and all Disney
stickers.
We're told that we need to constantly bring in what's new but
if we can only break even because we wind up selling product at
reduced prices, the owners never get ahead (pay off debt, enhance
services, etc.).
This is a huge problem that faces the independent retailers. A
handful of companies (usually those started by scrapbook
storeowners) understand and are working with independents on depth
requirements but many refuse to listen. Instead they tell us,
"You are LUCKY they don't make us purchase by the 100s."
(That is an exact quote, by the way).
When there were only a handful of scrapbook manufacturers from
whom people were somewhat content to buy, buying in 50s and 100s may
have been feasible. However, we have created a "churn and
burn" industry that literally devours its own. Faster than the
customer can ask, "What's new?" the next hottest thing is
being promoted and by the time we can get it to our shelves, the
craze is over and the store owners are "stuck."
Stores must be able to offer a variety to the customers. In order
to do this, we must be able to purchase in smaller quantities to
diversify product selection and sell through. Sell through is the
only way a store can be profitable.
Unlike the craft store which we are so often lumped into -- a
scrapbook is hugely personal. People want unique, different, and
personal items. People are looking for the "perfect"
paper, sticker, embellishment, etc. Most of our scrapbookers do not
want to create their own background papers, stickers, and
embellishments; they want to find them ready to use.
In essence, the personal nature of the project makes the
scrapbook store more like a Hallmark store. Hallmark succeeds, not
because it has 50 designs of six "Happy Mother's Day" card
designs, but because it has about 1-2 dozen of 50 "Happy
Mother's Day" card designs. People shop there because of the
variety and the belief that they will be able to find "the
perfect" card. They also sell gift items and impulse items to
increase ticket sales. (Lest we forget, the mark up on cards is also
usually more than 50%).
Our customers always want more variety, but purchasing printed
papers in the 50s reduces the total number of designs we can afford
to sell. By manufacturers offering papers in 25s, and stickers
packaged in the dozen (which, by the way, gives the store a
"higher end" look), stores can give customers a greater
variety and the perception that they will be able to find "the
perfect" items for their scrapbook without having to
increase inventory overhead. It increases product turns and reduces
risk to everyone.
There are many other issues that the Big Box "Deals"
and Internet competition have created, but the number one issue on
most storeowners' minds is product turns. Because the only way I can
"control" my inventory is to turn it faster. If I have to
constantly sell 50-75% of my product at a discount just to make room
for "the next hot thing" there is no profit, only
break-even. And, let's face it -- a store isn't going to get very
far if all they do is break even. Lisa Kanak, owner of
The Cropper's Corner
(Note: To read related comments from various industry
sections, click HERE
for Business-Wise and HERE
for Vinny Da Vendor. Business-Wise has the original email sent to
various industry veterans, and responses from a scrapbook company
veteran and a consultant. Vinny includes responses from vendors. To
comment on this or any of the columns, email mike@clnonline.com.)
YARN CONTINUES TO MAKE NEWS
The September issue of Bazaar said: "Crochet: The New
Knitting. Everyone's dropping her knitting needles for a crochet
hook." The piece referred to a photo of Kate Moss wearing a Dior
macrame-knit, spider-web dress, then suggested readers "get
started with an all-in-one kit from Lion Brand Yarn. (www.lionbrand.com)
with a portion of the proceeds benefitting the Susan B. Komen Breast
Cancer Foundation." (President David Blumenthal told CLN
Lion has been swamped with requests, and Lion has contributed
$10,000 to the Komen Foundation.)
In the 9/14 issue of Woman's Day, Editor in chief Jane
Chesnutt wrote, "I can't help but wonder if the resurgence of
knitting and crocheting's popularity is a response to the stress of
the technological age. It wasn't so many years ago that most of us
had three networks to choose from on TV and the Internet was unheard
of. With so much information vying for our attention now, it seems
logical that the quiet satisfaction of watching something of your
own making unfold before your eyes is the perfect antidote for
over-informed, over-stressed lives." The issue also included a
number of attractive how-to projects.
Lion Brand Yarn won Vendor of the Year at the recent Michaels
vendor meetings. The company is also co-publishing various annual
magazines, including Simply Creative Crochet (on newsstands
in Oct.), Knit.1 (Oct.), and Knit It (Jan.).
JO-ANN'S BEATS ESTIMATES
Net income for the quarter ended July 31 was $0.5 million
($0.02/diluted share) compared with a net loss of $2.2 million
($0.10) a year ago. Analysts had expected a $0.02 loss. Sales rose
3.3% to $371.0 million and same-store were up increased 3.1%. As a
result, the company increased its expected earnings for the year by a
nickel to $2.25-$2.30/diluted share, excluding the pre-tax charge of
$4.2 million recorded in the first quarter related to the company's
debt refinancing.
A pleased Chair/CEO Alan Rosskamm said, "We have now
achieved gross margin rate improvement while maintaining positive
same-store sales growth for four consecutive quarters. We are well
positioned for an exciting second half, with our inventory levels
and our merchandising strategies aligned as we head into the
important second half. We now have a total of 30 superstores that
are the smaller, more efficient 35,000 sq.-ft. prototype. Our
superstores now represent over 30% of total revenues and are
expected to meaningfully contribute to the second half sales
performance."
For the third quarter, execs project lower earnings than a year
ago because of the 60th anniversary promotion held last
year.
Jo-Ann's opened three superstores in the quarter and an
additional five in the first two weeks of the third quarter,
including its 100th. Year-to-date, Jo-Ann's has opened 16
superstores and one traditional store, and closed 46 traditional
stores. For the balance of the year, the company expects to open 13
superstores and close 25 traditional stores. The current store count
is 762 traditional stores and 101 superstores.
HANCOCK: A TOUGH QUARTER
For the quarter ended Aug. 1, there was a net loss of $2.7
million ($0.15/diluted share) compared to a profit of $1.6 million
($0.09) a year ago. Sales dropped 6.6% to $89.8 million and
same-store sales fell 6.7%. The latest results missed a mean
estimate of five analysts polled by Thomson First Call, which
predicted a loss of $0.04, Dow Jones News reported.
During the quarter Hancock opened 11 stores and closed eight.
Hancock plans to open 10-12 stores and close 7-8 in this quarter.
The current store count is 433.
To read the complete press release, including the comments and
analysis by CEO Larry Kirk, visit www.hancockfabrics.com,
click on Investor Relations, then Press Releases.
CONSUMER
SCRAPBOOK SHOWS SLATED FOR 2005
Although the attendance at some of the consumers shows dipped a
bit this year, sponsors believe its due to the increase in the
number of shows rather than a sign of declining consumer interest.
And they're backing up that theory by adding shows in new cities
next year.
Memories Expos. For its ninth year, Memories Community has
added three trade/consumer Expos to its schedule, bringing
the total to seven. The schedule: Apr. 1-2, Las Vegas ... Apr.
29-30, Somerset, NJ ... May 20-21, St. Charles, IL ... June 17-18,
Columbus, OH ... Sept. 9-10, Pasadena, CA ... Oct. 6-8, Orlando ...
Nov. 11-12, Denver. The Expos are open to everyone, but Memories
Community members enjoy free show admission, booth space discounts,
opportunities to sponsor classes and crop parties, class discounts,
free subscriptions to Memories Community magazine and
newsletter, etc. Annual dues are Specialty Services $75/yr.,
Retail$150/yr., Corporate $250/yr. For info, visit www.memoriesexpo.com,
call 740-452-4541, or email memories@offinger.com.
Great American Scrapbook Convention. June 9-11, Arlington, TX
... June 16-17, Chantilly, VA ... July 29-30, Grand Rapids, MI ...
Aug. 19-20, San Antonio, TX ... Sept. 28-Oct. 1 (with Women Create),
Ogden, UT. For more, call 801-627-3700, or visit www.greatamericanscrapbook.com
and www.womencreate.com.
C
1. It's that time of year again when the chains have their
"vendor-partner" meetings. I've received numerous calls
about the demands of the chains, and it seems this time vendors are
reaching their limits. (Of course, they've said that before, and
somehow find a way to go along with at least some of the chains'
requirements.)
2. One of the responses to my scrapbook email was a former
employee of Primedia who talked about the business seminars
at the annual MemoryTrends show that occurs later this month.
Years ago when I was editor of Craftrends, I gave a number of
seminars at trade shows. ("Improving Your Store
Newsletter", "Low-Cost Marketing Tips", etc.) Every
seminar reminded me of my days as an English teacher in a Peoria, IL
high school when I first graduated from college. The similarity was
this:
The parents of my A students always attended Parent-Teacher
Night. The parents of the F students, the ones I really needed to
talk to, were never there. Twenty years later, the savvy,
business-oriented retailers filled my seminars. The retailers who
opened stores because they loved cross stitch, or crafts, or
whatever, were never there. They were too busy taking product
workshops, which were more fun.
HURRICANES. Kudos to Wal-Mart for its efforts to help
the victims of Hurricane Charley. The Lakeland (FL) Ledger reported
the discounter has allowed one vacant property to be used as a
staging area for the National Guard and FEMA officials, allowed
another property to be used as a homeless shelter, sent 300 trucks
filled with basic supplies totaling $250,000, and donated $150,000
to Florida Red Cross chapters ... Toys R Us donated and
delivered two full truck loads of baby supplies and toys to the
Sarasota branch Red Cross's warehouse. (And our best wishes to
readers hit by Hurricane Frances.)
LOOKING: Experienced industry pro with extensive business, employment law, intellectual property, contracts, and marketing knowledge seeking executive-level position. Graduate degree. Willing to relocate. For more, call Mike
Hartnett 309-935-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
DUCKWALL-ALCO. For quarter ended Aug. 1, earnings from
continuing operations totaled $1,234,000 ($0.28/diluted share). Net
sales rose 0.8% to $109.6 million, and same-store sales rose 0.1%.
Like Rag Shops, the company is hiring a consulting firm to
develop a revised business plan and "examine other means of
enhancing stockholder value ...." This may be in reaction to a
Reuters report that the third-largest shareholder may try to force
the sale of the chain. For many months the company's sales report
would cite crafts as a strong category, but recently sales and
profits have been flat or fallen, and crafts has not been mentioned.
KIDS. Playthings magazine listed Michaels as
the 24th largest toy toy retailer in the U.S.
PEOPLE. Industry veteran Frank De Roberts is Dir. of
Marketing for Lion Brand Yarn. Frank has worked for Robinson
Anton and Coats & Clark ... Making Memories promoted
Andrew Williamson to Dir. of Marketing. Previously he had worked at Kellys
Crafts.
LAWSUITS. Wal-Mart and Target are being sued by the
Illinois attorney general's office which claims the discounters did
not collect sales taxes for merchandise sold on their web sites
between 1999 and 2002, the Chicago Sun Times reported..
HOBBIES. The Radio Control Hobby Trade Assn. re-elected Mark
Schwing (Electronic Model Systems) and Janet Ottmers (Horizon
Hobby) to their second three-year term on the board of
directors. Newly elected to his first three-year term is Ed Rogala (Midwest
Products/Falcon Trading) and Wil Byers (Kiona Publishing)
as alternate.
XMAS. The Christmas shopping season will be two days longer
than it was last year.
FLORALS. We're hearing that single-stem florals are not the
dynamo they once were. Among the reasons: 1. More types of
stores are carrying florals, thereby siphoning off business. 2.
Price pressures keep lowering the quality, and consumers are
starting to rebel. 3. Consumers can now buy finished bouquets
rather than individual stems and arranging them.
CONDOLENCES. Our very best wishes to Robert Workman, CEO of Provo
Craft, whose mother, Thea, passed away last week at the age of
75. Thea and her husband, Croft, founded Provo as a retail store
more than 40 years ago. Now a leader in crafts and scrapbooking,
Provo has more than 800 employees.
BOTTLE CAPS. Yes, they've become a craft/scrapbook item. (We
wouldn't have believed it either if we hadn't seen Suzanne McNeil of
Design Originals wearing an attractive really bottle
cap necklace at the CHA Summer show. Now they're embellishments and
papers, too. Visit www.d-originals.com.
MEDIA. The 19th series of America Sews with Sue Hausmann uplinks
to PBS stations Oct. 3. Sponsors include Husqvarna Viking, Jo-Ann's
Sulky of America, The Warm Co., Hewlett Packard, Rowenta, Rit,
ErgoSew, The Vintage Workshop/Indygo Junction, Krause Publications,
Havel's, Kandi, David Textiles, Martingale, and Cutting Corners ...
A new PBS series, In The Studio with Priscilla Hauser, will
be available in March. Cutter Productions is the producer.
Note: CLN will profile one company per issue, which will
remain online for at least a year. A Profile is a perfect way for a
new company to let itself be known to the industry, or for an
established company to enhance its reputation by showing the
industry its history, diversity of products, personnel, etc. For
more information on how your company can be profiled, call Mike
Hartnett at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
To read earlier Profiles, click HERE.
To learn about some of the latest jobs available in this and
related industries, click on Jobs in the left-hand column or click HERE.
A. C. Moore (ACMR). Last*: 21.74 ... Change**: -1.57
Hancock Fabrics (HKF). Last*: 11.22 ... Change**: -0.41
Jo-Ann Stores (JAS). Last*: 27.29 ... Change**: +1.73
Michaels (MIK). Last*: 58.00 ... Change**: +6.30
Rag Shops (RAGS). Last*: 3.61 ... Change**: +0.05
Wal-Mart (WMT). Last*: 53.25 ... Change**: -0.09
CLN Retail Index. Last*: 172.79 ... Change**: +3.6%
Dow Jones Index. Last*: 10,260.20 ... Change**: +4.4%
1.
For more information on how your business can be the
subject of a "Business Profile" call Mike Hartnett at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
2. If you want a hard-copy of this issue, click on
"Printer Friendly version".
3. If your company is a paid subscriber, everyone in the main
office is welcome to register, free. Just click on "Current
Subscribers Click Here To Register."
4. If you want to recommend CLN to a friend, use the
"Tell Your Friends" box on the home page.
5. Creative Leisure News is regularly published the
first and third Mondays of each month. Because August has five
Mondays, your next issue will be Monday, September 6. Happy Labor
Day!